Peer Review Process

Every manuscript submitted to El-Mizzi: Jurnal Ilmu Hadis is independently reviewed by at least two reviewers in the form of “double-blind review.” The decision for publication, amendment, or rejection is based upon their reports and recommendations. In certain cases, the editor may submit an article for review to a third reviewer before making a final decision, if deemed necessary.

The review process is conducted objectively and confidentially to ensure academic integrity, originality, and scholarly contribution. Reviewers evaluate manuscripts based on several criteria, including the relevance of the topic, methodological rigor, theoretical contribution, clarity of argumentation, use of sources and references, as well as compliance with the journal’s writing guidelines. Authors are required to revise their manuscripts in accordance with the reviewers’ comments and editorial suggestions within the specified timeline before the article can proceed to publication.